We’re in that season where most people are watching scary movies. Past years have seen me digging into Universal Monsters, some of Hammer Studios’ offerings, and other classic, spooky films. For whatever reason, this year the best I’ve been able to muster is watching It’s the Great Pumpkin, Charlie Brown, which is, of course, delightful.
But I’m more than ready for Noir-vember. Bring on the crime movies!
However, I’ve recently watched two recent releases that fall into the horror genre. I won’t be doing full reviews here, but as I’ve thought about these movies I’ve noticed an interesting commonality that’s worth comment. Both of them came out this year, received criticism for not focusing enough on the monsters, and both are about alien invasions. Yet there are very different movies.
First, is A Quiet Place: Day One
This is a prequel. The first two movies were set in rural/suburban small-town America, while this movie has all new characters (with one exception) and takes place in New York and its boroughs. It asks, “How did the rest of the world react to the invasion?” As you’re probably aware, these savage alien creatures hunt by sound and ferociously attack with blinding speed anything that makes a sound.
The first movie had some wondering if it was about being politically conservative in Hollywood.
If you’re coming to Day One for answers about where the aliens come from, why they’re here, or a bit of information about how they can be overcome if only the right people could compare notes, you’ll be disappointed. If you’re looking for a movie with a queen monster that makes it personal and our heroes have to turn the tables on, you’ll be really disappointed.
This is a character study, with the monsters making for a metaphor.
Second, is Arcadian
Once again, we’re dealing with an extraterrestrial threat. These monsters only come out at night, and seem to have weakened humanity with a virus before starting direct attacks. Like those in A Quiet Place, they’re completely animalistic, though they also seem to learn and adapt. The family trying to survive in this film lives on what appears to be an Irish farm, even though they’re American, and that doesn’t really matter.
Because this too is a character study with heavy metaphors.
Horror fans were upset with these movies. They move slowly, meditatively, placing their entire focus on the people and not the monsters. Yes, there are jump scares and gore. But creative kills aren’t the point. Day One and Arcadian are about what it means to be human while living with an oppressive terror. Monster movies have often reflected societal fears, so it’s worth asking, why these movies and why now?
I don’t know that I have an answer. The best answer may not be apparent for decades.
But I suspect the reason has something to do with our fears of self-expression. Say the wrong thing online and you might lose your job. So don’t make a sound. You can try to live a safe life and never “go out in the dark.” But if you aren’t currently living through a tragedy, someday you will, because that’s life. Ultimately, we must learn how to accept that everything has consequences and they may be painful, now or later.
It’s an alien horror that only arrived after Man took the fruit in the garden.
We weren’t created for this.
So we make movies and tell stories to help us adapt, survive, and thrive.