All anyone is talking about right now is how Disney’s Star Wars: The Acolyte has been canceled. This is hardly shocking news. The budget wasn’t scaled to the potential audience of gay Star Wars fans, when anyone with half a brain knew it wouldn’t appeal to the wider fanbase, and no one but YouTube critics watched it. So it's not getting a second season. That such a nonstory is getting so much attention is wearisome and disappointing.
So moving on.
What no one is talking about is that The Ark got a second season, and it’s really good. If you check IMdB the fourth episode, “The Other You,” has an 8.4/10, which is far better than any episode of The Acolyte. That Dean Devlin and Syfy are quietly telling great stories, while the Paramount and Disney powerhouses are not, should be all over the YouTubes, but apparently I’m the only one paying attention to things I like and enjoy.
Shame on the YouTubers!
There will be spoilers for The Ark episode 4.
At the end of episode three, James Brice vanished from The Ark leaving only his empty coveralls. Naturally, everyone else in the room is shocked and distraught. “The Other You” opens with them processing what had just happed, before moving our attention to a cryopod releasing its occupant. It’s Cat! Wait, isn’t she dead? Isn’t actress Christina Wolfe signed to another series and therefore unable to come back?
Commercial break!
But we don’t care why or how she's back, because Cat, the former social media star turned ship’s therapist, is a great character. Also, between seasons she got even more attractive. That’s not the only that’s changed, as Cat suddenly has a British accent, which only makes her hotter, but now we are asking questions. We’re not the only ones, and those aren’t the only questions.
Looking out the windows The Ark, the crew realizes there’s nothing out there.
Like, nothing nothing. No space. No stars. Just void.
Eventually, the crew figures out that the faster than light drive bumped them into a vacuum between realities, where they neither exist nor don’t. Cat (now going by Catrina, and a brilliant scientist to boot) comes from an alternate reality. Which naturally means that Brice is now running around naked in her reality, where he also died. Bad for him, but an opportunity to inject some humor from the writers for us.
Commercial break!
I’m not going to try and explain all the science-y jargon they use to justify this situation and untangle realities. That’s not really important in stories like this. Rather, the focus remains firmly on the characters and the concept. I’m thankful that the writers didn’t go the classic Star Trek or Buffy the Vampire Slayer route where the alternate universe is full of evil doppelgangers, but neither did they make it a utopia. The alternate reality in which Brice finds himself is exactly the same, with good and bad, but different. Some people have better lives in this world, others have it worse.
As Catrina and Brice share with them how things are different, everyone experiences some heartache for what might have been, or gratefulness for what is not.
That’s good writing.
Everyone is allowed to feel things as fully fleshed out characters. There’s love and hate, anger and remorse. The conflict that supplies the tension is frequently broken with moments of laugh-out-loud humor that feels entirely appropriate. I could have done without Felix kissing another man, but that’s the entertainment world we live in, and I’m left to wish for my own alternate reality where screenwriters don’t feel obliged to insert stuff like that.
What I’m saying is, “The Other You” has all the elements which every episode of The Acolyte reportedly lacks.
And as such, it deserves some attention.