The Ark is back, and better than ever!
Season one ended on a big cliffhanger and no promise of a series renewal, but thankfully it survived against all odds, just like our crew. This isn’t going to be a summary of the first two episodes, so much as some general impressions. I know many people were turned off by the first season’s chintzy special effects, weak acting, and formulaic writing. I’ve seen at least one person complain that it’s not a sci-fi show, but a soap opera, which couldn’t be more misguided. But we’ll get into that.
So how is season two looking so far?
Very, very good.
I have to wonder how many of the people who walked away during the first season went ahead and hate-watched all of the new Star Wars shows. The Ark may offend your highbrow or hard science-fiction sensibilities, but it will never subvert your expectations in a cruel way or preach a false, woke message. True,there are gay characters and girl-bosses, but I never get the sense that these characters are there to push an agenda so much as to cast a wide net. Dean Devlin and company don’t have fans to spare. They’re trying to build something.
All Disney knows how to do anymore is tear down.
What’s good: Right off the bat the stakes are high and not everyone from the first season survives. I said that Captain Garnet is something of a girl-boss, but the writers take care to make her a feminine character, not just a woman playing a part written for a man. When she pulls everyone together in the midst of a crisis to confess that she’s never known what it’s like to have a family until she met them, it feels right. She’s the captain of this damaged ship with its crew of misfits, and she navigates it like a single-mom who knows she’s in over her head.
Star Trek was always about the bonds of friendship, and no one calls it a soap opera.
Also good, the formula seems to be gone. The writing in the first season was too predictable. There was a mystery that would arc over a few episodes, a problem to solve from the last episode, and the introduction of a new problem. Maybe the writers needed that structure while figuring out the characters and seeing what the show would become. Now it seems that the training wheels have come off and they’re able to freestyle in a way that feels more organic. The balance of drama and humor is also refreshing.
If you can’t find satisfaction in a good joke from a dire situation, when should you?
I also appreciate that The Ark continues to explore contemporary issues in ways that aren’t too on-the-nose. In the first season a major theme was the dangers of hero worship. This season seems to be tackling the problem of parents who mutilate their children for their own satisfaction and the consequences of that. A continuing theme is that of redemption. The Ark has never been afraid of allowing good characters to do terrible things, suffer the consequences, and ask for forgiveness. But can an evil person who's done unforgivable things change and find acceptance? We’ll find out.
Even the not so good is tempered with positives.
Hearing a male character say, “My husband,” will never not be distracting and feel like pandering. It is what it is. They’re coming dangerously close to making Felix a one note character because of it. Most of what we actually see are heterosexual romances blooming, and it’s refreshing to have to have a show that doesn’t shy away from that. Also irritating are the budget special effects. Thankfully, the show knows its limits and doesn’t use them very often. But perhaps the most distracting change is that Ryan Adams, who plays Angus, looks to have gained 15 much needed pounds (the kid wasn’t just gawky, but gaunt!) between seasons. They’re covering it up well by keeping him in a hospital bed and not giving us a good look at him, but we can tell.
And that’s it for the negatives!
Overall, new episodes of The Ark are still one of the highlights of my week. If you miss wholesome, optimistic, inoffensive sci-fi, you’re not going to find anything better on TV right now.