While audiences don’t seem to be flocking to Kevin Costner’s Horizon: An American Saga - Chapter 1, it does seem to have people talking about westerns again. That’s always a good thing. The western is to story what jazz is to music. Both are as close to purely American made as you can get. Of course one can easily trace these things back across oceans and time, but neither could have ever come into existence anywhere else. In the 1960s, it’s been argued, we got cowboy fatigue like today we’re talking about superhero fatigue. But did we really?
Maybe filmmakers just lost sight of what made those genres special.
From the birth of film through the early 70s Hollywood pumped out hundreds of oaters. Eventually, other countries started getting in on the action. Now anyone who wants to explore them can find it intimidating, as friend of mine recently confessed. There’s just so many, and the ones with the highest praise tend to be serious and depressing. I love westerns for their aspirational aspects, and, while I can appreciate the more serious and realistic films, if I just dove in on what’s considered the best of the best I’d burn out. The Searchers is amazing.
It’s also as depressing as heck.
Within the genre, there are movies for everyone: those who want realism, those who want to escape, movies for children, melodramas for the ladies, and outrageous comedies. The fun thing about the comedies is that the more westerns you watch the funnier they get, because they tend to be very self-referential. A James Garner spoof, like Support Your Local Sheriff, which I’ve seen countless times since childhood, is even better now that I’ve seen James Stewart’s Winchester ‘73.
Jimmy didn’t feel the same, of course.
So where does one start? With John Wayne, of course! If you can stand really old movies, Angel and the Badman is a great film from early in his career, before he became a star. Then I’d suggest moving on to Stagecoach (50% at Amazon at the time I’m writing this), the movie that made him an icon. From there, just alternate between the movies he did with John Ford and Howard Hawks for a nice balance between serious movies and fun actioners. Though basically the same movie done twice, Rio Bravo and El Dorado are two of my favorites.
But what if you get tired of The Duke?
Well, James Stewart’s westerns, like the aforementioned Winchester ‘73, are definitely worth a look. After seeing him as a romantic lead, or a confused man in a Hitchcock film, one might not expect him to have the grit to pull off a gunslinger. But there was steele in his backbone and ice in his eyes when he needed it. Another actor I’ve only recently come to appreciate is Audie Murphy, whose soft voice and boy-next-door good looks were very deceiving. The most decorated soldier of WWII in real life, he could bring intensity to a black hat role in No Name on the Bullet (arguably the best performance of his short career) and humor in Ride a Crooked Trail (both available in a nice box set, along with the very good Duel at Silver Creek, that’s 49% off right now).
After that, the comedies.
I’ll keep this short: Support Your Local Gunfighter, The Sheepman, Maverick, and of course Blazing Saddles are all essentials if you love westerns. There are many other comedies out there, and some are very good. But these are the four on my shelf that I’ll watch again and again. They’re all clever and made with true affection for the genre, while still good stories in their own right. Sometimes parody signals the dying gasps of something once nurtured. These films remind us why we’ve always loved westerns.
Finally, the one-offs.
If you find that you really love westerns and want to hit some of the greats that don’t have John Wayne, James Stewart, Clint Eastwood, and others who defined, and were in turn defined by the cowboy movie, there’s still plenty to explore. Shane stars Alan Ladd, who more often did noir films, and is iconic. Humphrey Bogart and James Cagney star in The Oklahoma Kid, which is also very good. And if you’ve only seen the 2007 remake, you owe it to yourself to see the original 3:10 to Yuma (45% off at the moment).
High Noon can kick rocks.
Be sure to check out my friend Rob’s list of the 100 best westerns of all time, which is mostly wrong (I’m kidding, Rob!), and still 100% better than the recent list from Indiewire.