Out of all the great literary detectives, my favorite is Nero Wolfe, or maybe Archie Goodwin. But since they usually arrive as a matched set I guess it doesn’t make much difference, if any. I’ve always liked it when genres are mashed together, and Rex Stout’s novels are the perfect blend of the genteel European detective (Wolfe) with the hardboiled American gumshoe (Goodwin).
I haven’t read the entire Wolfe corpus, but at some point I’ll probably get there.
Murder by the Book, is (according to Amazon) the 19th Nero Wolfe Mystery. Published in 1951, it was the first full length novel Stout had written in a while, seeming to prefer writing collections of short stories. The book opens with Inspector Cramer coming to Wolfe for help. In his hand he’s got a list of meaningless names, which is somehow connected to the murder of a law clerk. Unfortunately, Wolfe has no insight.
A month later, circumstances change with the arrival of a new client.
Wellman, a grocery store owner from Illinois, askes Wolfe to investigate the murder of his daughter, who was a reader for a New York publishing house. The only thing the grieving father knows is that her last assignment was reading a novel by Baird Archer, and that after meeting with him she was found dead. Somehow Wolfe remembers that name from Cramer’s list and we’re off to the races.
I’m not sure I like this one very much.
Many of the Wolfe stories are quite funny, and, while never fully removed from the real world and human emotion, veer aware from the uncomfortable. Reading Murder by the Book, there were several times I found myself wincing. [Minor spoilers] The first time is when Archie goes to interview the mother of a second murdered girl, only to find that the adoring mother has not yet been informed. Later, Wolfe receives a written confession for all the murders and let’s just say the first wasn’t a clean killing.
The long letter, recounted in full, was a device I didn’t care for, either.
While there is some humor in the first third (especially Archie’s party with a bunch of drunk secretaries), the story just gets darker and darker, until we realize that this might feature the most cold-blooded killer Wolfe ever sent to the chair. Stout writes masterfully, of course, and nothing is untrue to the world he created. It’s just a more chilling side, and sadder side, of that world.
Many mystery aficionados say they return to this one again and again, and I understand why.
Murder by the Book is the full package: mystery, twists, turns, humor, horror, and love in all its various forms. The dialog is crisp and the prose is descriptive. But it will be a while before I want to read it again.