Saddle up, partner! Today we’re talking about remakes again.
One of my all-time favorite movies is Rio Bravo, directed by Howard Hawks and starring John Wayne. But sometimes I think I like the remake, El Dorado, directed by Howard Hawks and starring John Wayne, a little more. Recently, I watched the remake of El Dorado, Rio Lobo, which was directed by Howard Hawks and stars John Wayne.
And I doubt that’s anyone’s favorite.
I'm not sure anyone was happy about making Rio Lobo or the finished product. When Howard Hawks sent Wayne the script, the actor reportedly said something to the effect of, "Why bother? We've already made this movie twice." Except for Wayne, Hawks wasn't happy with his cast. Mexican hunk Jorge Rivero is no Ricky Nelson, or even James Caan. John Wayne felt upstaged by Jack Elam in a way he never did by Walter Brennan. And as the love interest, Jennifer O’Neill is appealing, even if she feels more 1960’s than 1860’s.
No surprise, since Hawks found her unmanageable.
He also had problems with the script, so he called in Leigh Brackett to fix things. By “fix things” he meant make it even more like the other two. Brackett reluctantly did as he asked, though one has to think that the woman who’d written several westerns by this point, landmark sci-fi novels, and who went on to write a screenplay for The Empire Strikes Back at George Lucas’s request (he rejected it), probably had some fresh ideas.
By the time it was all over, even Hawks had to admit it was a dud. It was his final film.
The critics complained that Wayne was too old and fat for the part, and his clearly poor health didn't help to counter the argument. Opening scenes set during the Civil War would be laughably implausible if one dared to laugh at the Duke, and critics once were daring. But years later Roger Ebert took a kinder assessment in his review, and I'm inclined to agree.
Wayne and Hawks movies are American rituals, and even when they’re tired they’re still entertaining.
Watching John Wayne, a good looking kid, a couple of beautiful women, and an old coot hole up in the jail to shoot it out with the bad guys is always a delight. That we get to see how Hawks did it in the styles of the 50s, 60s, and 70s, adds some texture audiences of the times couldn't appreciate. Unfortunately, by the 70s the genre was getting as worn out as the director and star, and you feel it.
Even the colors are muted.
Rio Lobo is the least of the three, but in some ways it's the most ambitious because everyone involved knew it still needed something fresh. The train robbery at the beginning is novel and provides a backstory distinct from the other films. It’s only later that the story settles into the old routine. Even if I can’t say the movie is good, I admire the old men for still putting in the work.
In this era of remakes, it's refreshing to see more thought and craft put into one, even when it's the same director, screenwriter, and star doing it.