Maybe it’s the weather, maybe it’s my circumstances, but I haven’t really been in the Christmas mood this year. I decorated the house out of a sense of obligation, despite the sense that I’d just done this, and I put on Christmas music in the car. Usually by now I’ve watched several holiday movies, but this year I’ve gravitated more towards things like Die Hard and Lethal Weapon.
Take that as you will.
But over the weekend I felt an inkling of a desire for something festive and decided to pursue that, not with the movies everyone watches, but some forgotten classics. And I’ve got another that I know I’ll get to later. If you’re fighting in your inner Grinch and need some fresh material to keep you in the Christmas spirit, here are three movies I love.
The Shop Around the Corner (1940)
When you think of Jimmy Stewart and Christmas, you think of It’s A Wonderful Life and with good reason. Still, it’s a shame that that film has completely overshadowed his other Christmas movie. Mostly remembered today in IMDb trivia as being based off the same play as You’ve Got Mail (which I’ve never seen), The Shop Around the Corner is worth visiting again and again.
I admit, I had to see the movie about three times before falling in love with it. That’s it’s based on a play is obvious, and setting it in a Hungarian village where half the people speak like Americans gave me mental whiplash. But on this most recent watch I found a deep appreciation for the subtleties of acting and directing on display.
The plot is fine-tuned for maximum drama without every drifting into melodrama. We want to see every character find true happiness, but that happiness must be earned through trials. That it works so well in such a small setting creates a masterclass in storytelling. But it’s Stewart and Margaret Sullavan’s understated performances that tie it all together.
Director Ernst Lubitsch also works in subtleties. Notice how often the camera isn't focused on who is speaking, but instead the listener's reaction. Or we only see the person talking and the listener's reaction is left entirely to our imagination. Also note how Stewart and Sullivan are in frame together in parallel with a gulf of separation, and then an invisible barrier between them. But when they finally connect they move into a right angle.
There are no wasted moments, and every moment is perfect.
Holiday Affair (1949)
I freely admit that personal bias may be skewing my opinion here. A kind-hearted, lonely old bachelor has an amazing Christmas and wins a place in a beautiful woman's life and family.
Just stick a knife in my heart and twist it already!
Janet Leigh is a war widow making ends meet as a comparison shopper. Basically she works as a spy for a department store, gathering prices before stores were required to advertise them. When Robert Mitchum's salesman catches her and doesn't turn her over to security he gets fired.
He takes an immediate liking to the single mom and her kid, but Leigh is too damaged to see that he's a better fit for her than her fiancee. And as much as Mitchum tries to do the decent thing and leave, fate keeps pushing them back together.
It's a sincere, heartwarming story, with some great comedy (don't miss Harry Morgan in a bit part!) and even better drama.
Not to be missed.
The Thin Man (1934)
I've watched The Thin Man every Christmas for over ten years. It's less of a Christmas movie than even Die Hard, but it does feature a Christmas party. So good enough.
Nick Charles (William Powell) was a private eye before meeting and marrying Nora (Myrna Loy), but when a former client's daughter asks him to find her father, he's reluctantly brought back into the game. Eventually, a body turns up. But who is it? And whodunnit?
All of that is incidental, though. We're here for the banter between a husband and wife who are crazy about each other. And the dialog sparkles.