When I saw the trailer for No One Will Save You it didn’t really inspire any interest. As much I like Kaitlyn Dever from her work on Justified and Last Man Standing, I’m not such a fan that I’ll watch anything with her in it. However, after listening to an interview with writer/director Brian Duffield and the glowing praise of Chris Gore, I decided to give it a chance.
If only to see a new movie.
The film (available on Hulu) opens as Brynn (Dever) goes about her idyllic day. Initially we’re unsure of the era. There’s nothing distinct about her homemade dress or the decoration of her house to give us any clues. It could be anywhere between the 1950’s and now. There’s something strange about the girl, too, as she practices a smile and friendly wave in the bathroom mirror. Strange, and sad. Why is she all alone in this big, old house? Why doesn’t she remember how to smile?
Give it time. We shall see.
And I mean see. There’s next to no dialog in this movie. Duffield said in the interview that as he was writing the screenplay he was well into it before realizing Brynn hadn’t spoken and decided to just keep it going. It’s a testament to Dever’s skill as an actress that she’s able to fill the screen just by her presence. We feel for this lonely girl, especially when she drives into town in her Subaru Outback (oh, so it’s present day-ish) and the whole town shuns her.
And that hurts.
That night things get even weirder. After a peaceful afternoon and evening of writing a letter to someone named Maude, solo dancing lessons with paper footprints on the living room floor, and a homemade dinner with a glass of wine, Brynn goes to bed. It’s well after dark when she hears a noise. And it’s an alien. We’re not talking E.T. looking to phone home. No, we’re still not talking at all, but if we were it’d be about Close Encounters of the Third Kind meets Signs, with a dash of Poltergeist.
It’s scary.
Brynn’s homey home becomes a house of horrors as lights turn off and on, doors open and close, and a gray alien stalks the halls. Honestly, as much as I shared Brynn’s fright, I found myself wishing that this movie’s protagonist would do something. And then, at just the right moment, she does. I won’t spoil the surprise. But from this point the entire movie is about Brynn first seeking help, then attempting to escape, then trying to survive. As she fights she’s forced to reflect on why it is she’s alone.
But do we care about backstory when there’s a full blown alien invasion going on?
Should we care?
Unfortunately, this where the movie falls short. Duffield clearly wants us to care about Brynn’s origin and does his best to tie it into the climax and resolution, yet fails to demonstrate why it matters. Brynn’s outcome is somewhat determined by what she’s experienced in her past. That shouldn’t be a spoiler. But the film’s contrived and convoluted ending leaves me wondering if it’s what a sympathetic audience would want for her.
This could be a long episode of The Twilight Zone, except there are rules there.
In Rod Serling’s world, the characters' heart determined their outcomes. Sometimes it was just. Sometimes it was tragic. But either way, the contrast was black and white. Though No One Will Save You brings to mind the classic Twilight Zone episode “The Invaders,” the twist is nowhere near as satisfying. The tonal shift doesn’t shock so much as sit there.
Well, what am I supposed to do with that? I don’t know, and ultimately I guess I don’t care.