Everyone is talking about the culture war, and no one is using it for art. Oh sure, there are plenty of people using the concept to sell their books and movies and behind-the-paywall podcast monologs. But who out there is using the fears that come with a war to fuel good stories? If woke is the monster, we can acknowledge that monsters are real and can be slain. Social media feeds on catastrophism and despair, becoming self-fulfilling prophesy. Our fiction should take every opportunity to do the opposite.
It’s time to Make Monster Movies Great Again.
Last year PBS posted a short history video titled The Golden Age of Movie Monsters, which explores the origins and influence of Universal’s enduring classics (the blu-ray set is pretty affordable, if you’ve never seen them). In it, Dr. Emily Zarka notes that the monster movie genre arrived while Americans were still reeling from WWI and the Great Depression, and the monsters represented something: the anxieties of the time.How high is anxiety now, or would it be if not for the numbing agents we have so readily available?
The monster was fear of the outsider. Today immigration is a chief concern of voters, and let’s not forget the aliens hovering in the sky.
The mad scientist was fear of man playing God and using the occult to arrive at unnatural ends. Today we’re making prayer candles with Dr. Fauci’s face on them, and let’s not forget that CERN once did a pagan ritual at their lab (they promise it was just a joke).
Universal Horror explored fears around changing gender roles, the crumbling family, and the evolving social structure. Today those concerns are back with a vengeance.
What happens in these movies? More often than not, older men confront the evil with Christian symbols. Order is, at least to some degree, restored through a steady hand, despite the monster’s lingering chaos. At the same time their evil is never totally defeated, because that’s the fallen world in which we live, and how Hollywood makes sequels.
They made the monsters and the movie world familiar, real, true.
Unfortunately, we’ve lost our knack for making subtle metaphors. So today there’s increased danger that the message overwhelms the movie. While I like Nefarious, it suffers from a lack of subtlety. Storytellers must focus on making art that is timeless and true. If it’s true today, it will still be true 100 years from now whatever the social issues of the day, and equally significant meanings can be drawn from the imagery at a later date.
There’s another reason monster movies can and should make a comeback.
Universal only got into the monster business because the movies could be made on the cheap and still be infinitely creative. That’s worth considering. We all know cheapie horror movies still make money, but I’m talking about a subset of that genre. Monster movies can be thoughtful and atmospheric, and needn’t rely on gore or big scares. They’re about ideas, horrible ideas, and exploring them in ways that thrill and excite the imagination. Universal’s monster movies may seem hokey today, or spoiled by Mel Brooks, but I think the climate is right to give them another try.
It’s time to Make Monster Movies Great Again