Over the weekend I revisited Rookie of the Year, a childhood favorite. I must have watched it many, many times, because at one point I looked over at my mom and remarked that I still knew what everyone was going to say before they said it. “I had nothing to do with that,” Mom said.
I remember it differently.
It must have been on my eleventh birthday that I got the movie on VHS. How it appeared on my parents’ radar, or why they decided to take a chance on it, I’ll never know. We didn’t pay much attention to movies in my house, and even less to sports. But having read the novelization I was pretty excited.
Adapting the screenplays from family films into YA novels used to be a thing.
Anyway, yesterday I had about an hour and forty-five minutes for a movie and decided to see if it holds up. So many years later, with so many more movies behind me, I noticed things I never noticed before. Like, Bill Conte did the score.
Not as iconic as Rocky, but the music provides more than just atmosphere.
If, like me, you haven’t seen Rookie of the Year in about 25, it’s the story of Henry (Thomas Ian Nicholas) a good kid, with some good buddies, who has a rough life, and a love for baseball. Unfortunately, he’s not very good at it. But after healing up from a broken arm, he discovers he can throw a 103mph fastball.
The next thing he knows, he’s pitching for the Chicago Cubs.
His reluctant mentor on the team is over-the-hill pitcher Chet “The Rocket” Steadman (Gary Busey), while Daniel Stern does double-duty as director and comic relief. I only now realize that Stern studied at the Don Knotts School of Comedy, and he nails the tone. Meanwhile, Busey does an excellent job portraying an aging athlete making peace with closing out his career. But it’s Nicholas who is the MVP, playing Henry as a likable, goofy, not-obnoxious boy.
And he’s all boy.
I wouldn’t say Rookie of the Year is politically incorrect or offensive, unless you are offended by reality. Henry never knew his dad and he’s looking for a father figure. Mary (Amy Morton), his mom, does a great job, but it’s obvious there’s a missing piece in his life. That’s real life in a fantasy film. As an adolescent, Henry and his friends are just starting to notice girls in a natural, wholesome, awkward way. Like most boys do. Henry and his buddies also have a falling out and get into a fistfight.
Moments later, they’re friends again. Because that’s true too.
By rooting this absurd story in deeper realities and never attempting to correct or amend the truth, the filmmakers set the stage for a story that endures 30 years later. It's a comfort movie for everyone. When truth is on your side all a storyteller needs is to affirm the good realities. Then there’s no need to preach or push The Message.