The story behind The Wise of Heart: A Modern-Day Re-Imagining of the Scopes Monkey Trial is almost as remarkable as the novel itself. When author Hans G. Schantz sat down at his computer to watch the 1988 TV adaptation of Inherit the Wind, he had no idea he would be inspired to write a book, or that his experience would parallel that of his main character.
As you may recall from reading the 1955 play in high school, Inherit the Wind is a fictionalized account of the Scopes Monkey Trial where a teacher was taken to court for teaching Darwinism in violation of state law. Today a new faith in the fluidity of gender holds the power, and woe to anyone who teaches biological science. Almost as soon as the movie started Schantz recognized the potential, switched off the movie, and set to work.
In this version Schantz’s protagonist is Dr. Mike Andrews, a right-leaning high school science teacher somewhere in rural America. A new law states that “it shall be unlawful for any teacher… to teach any theory that denies the gender definition adopted by any person, and to teach instead that gender identity has a biological meaning independent of any person’s chosen preference.” Andrews agrees to cross the line just enough to get arrested and stand trial. The school superintendent promises to cover any fines and provide for legal council, while President Buchmann of the local university, who helped draft the legislation, makes a deal with the district attorney to allow an outside prosecutor.
To ensure their (Buchmann uses they/them pronouns despite having been born a woman) side wins they reach out to Sen. Roxy Castillo, a feminist icon with her eye on the Oval Office. In response, the defense brings in Sen. Chad Travis, a drawling Texan and human embodiment of Conservative values. That Travis and Castillo have personal history adds an extra layer of intrigue.
The trial coverage is where the satire shines bright as Schantz takes coy jabs at the media machine. “Be sure to like, subscribe, and hit that little bell!” “Then the whole bus clapped!” “You’re watching the number one conservative videocast in the entire universe!” Just as it is in real life, hearing all the conflicting voices keeps us off balance. Who are we supposed to think is winning? Which social media personality is just spinning?
Caught in the middle is Buchmann’s daughter, Acey, who also happens to be Mike’s girlfriend. She represents most of us, kindhearted people who just want everyone to be nice and get along. When Mike is incentivized to apologize and put the whole mess behind him, she’s there to ask why he won’t. With the most dramatic arc of all the characters, Acey is arguably the unsung heroine of the novel.
One of the most difficult things an author must do is create antagonists who believe what he/she/they is doing is good and right. Castillo and Buchmann operate in an arena where they are certain facts, logic, and feelings stand with them. Many things can be (and have been) said about The Wise of Heart, yet no argument can be made that they are strawmanned (strawwomanned? strawpersoned?). Their words are taken verbatim from real world transgender activists. All Schantz had to do was hold up a mirror.
Perhaps that unflattering view is why Schantz ran into trouble. As an independent author, he relies on crowdfunding to publish his books. His initial Kickstarter campaign easily reached the $3,000 goal before it was abruptly canceled. The only reason given came in a generic form letter suggesting the previously approved novel had “Hateful or offensive content that fails to meet Kickstarter’s spirit of inclusivity by promoting discrimination, bigotry, or intolerance toward marginalized groups.”
Given Kickstarter’s reputation this was hardly a surprise. Just as the characters in the story found, a “spirit of inclusivity” only works one way. Schantz was able to restart crowdfunding on FundMyComic, more than doubling his initial goal and allowing him to have it illustrated and recorded as an upcoming audiobook.
John Grisham himself could hardly have written the detailed passages of scientific argument any better, as the courtroom scenes spark with interpersonal drama. These dueling characters are people we grow to love and hate, and when the story reaches its climax readers will find their hearts touched. This is the beauty of fiction, that we can learn, think, and grow, while remaining so personally engaged we won’t be quick to forget.