My friend James David Dickson recently noted that the MAGA crowd lives in a fantasyland, picturing MLK at Trump rallies, or Elon Musk running as Trump’s VP.
We know such things are impossible, improbable at best. Dickson follows up with, “You’re sitting around waiting to be saved by superheroes.” He’s dead-on right. Everyone fantasizing about how awesome it would be if MLK joined MAGA would have been, not too long ago, drawing Superman joining The Avengers. The Trump and Elon Musk some people imagine are no more real than Lex Luthor and Tony Stark, and it’s about time we grew up.
But I’m not a political commentator.
Andrew Klavan once said, “Imagination is where the future starts.” We’re forever trying to make the stories we tell ourselves come true. It’s human nature. In some ways, our stories become self-fulfilling prophesies. So what happens when our most popular genre is the superhero story? Small children imagine themselves as the heroes who do great and mighty things. But eventually reality sets in: we aren’t going to get bit by a radioactive spider, build a super suit, or become immortal. Oh, we’ll try. The transhumanist movement is working on immortality and superpowers, but ultimately those are the things of gods.
We give up on becoming Superman and settle for Jimmy Olson.
Jimmy Olson, as you may recall, is the normie who is always getting rescued. Even more than Lois Lane, he’s the punching bag for villains and heroes alike, and too caught up in his hero worship to care. He gets rescued! He’s got Superman’s attention. Things might get rough, but it’ll work out in the end.
We’re long overdue for a genre shift.
Americans invented superheroes, true. “Truth, justice, and the American way,” were things so revered we even expected strange visitors from other worlds to adopt them. Somewhere along the way (ie: the 1960’s) we lost faith in the American virtues. And it’s worth noting that it was in the 60’s that the Silver Age of comics started at about this time. Most of the superheroes we see on our movie screens now were born then. Something else started happening in that decade.
The western genre lost steam.
Westerns are arguably less of a genre for us than our native myth. England has knights. Asia has samurai. America has cowboys. Before we conjured up superheroes, the cowboy formed from the dust of cattle drives and smoke from campfires and six-shooters. But about the time Spider-Man was capturing the attention of young boys, John Wayne was nearing the end of the trail.
Why it mattes now:
True westerns are never about looking for a human savior to pull us out our difficulties. Even Shane, the archetypal gunfighter hero, rides out of the wilderness to inspire the people building civilization and impart wisdom to the next generation. Sadly, he must return to the wilderness, because it's no place for him. Many western stories acknowledge God and Christian virtue, because He is the eternal savior and those virtues are the bedrock for a decent and honorable life. The emphasis, however, is on strong individuals bonding together to bring order to the chaotic, wild west. Shane exists to inspire, but we're to identify with the family who takes him in and carry on after he's gone.
The superhero genre is candy for children that can be enjoyed by adults.
The western is the red meat everyone needs to be strong.
If we want a better culture now, we need to shift our focus away from stories where we’re victims waiting for rescue, and tell ourselves stories that inspire us to be strong individuals and help our neighbors. We have to move away from movies that celebrate false gods and abdicate responsibility in their presence.
We need to tell ourselves better stories in order to have a better future.