I learned something the other day.
Over the weekend one of the small towns around here had their annual celebration. I don’t know if this is common in other parts of the country, but around here every summer just about every little city, town, and village has a parade and other special events. On Sunday, this particular community had a bluegrass gospel concert. Last year I missed most of it, because I thought I’d left a burner on and raced back home to check (it was off).
But I digress.
In our rush to get out the door this year I neglected to grab a book or download anything to my phone. The music is nice, don’t get me wrong. But I can’t give it my undivided attention. Fortunately, I knew from past years where I could find a little library. Sometimes you’ll find a gem. So before I went inside I perused the offerings and came across The Scoop & Behind the Screen, which was written by more people than I care to list.
It’s two novellas, written in concert by some of mystery fiction’s greatest luminaries.
Dorothy L. Sayers wrote chapter one. Agatha Christie wrote chapter two. And so forth. In the second appendix Sayers explains how the stories were outlined and developed. There was some pre-planning, though in The Scoop three of the authors were required to use their wits to unravel the plot devised by the other three. Does it work? I haven’t finished the book yet. All Sayers says is, “The proof of a pudding is in the eating.”
There you are.
What I found most interesting, however, is the preface by Julian Symons, a mystery writer in his own right and also an historian of the genrel. In it he offers up what is known of the Detection Club, which is somewhat shrouded in a mystery of its own. Apparently no amount of sleuthing has been able to reveal when the club was founded. It was sometime circa 1930 and there’s a little book of Constitution Rules from 1932, though it seems the club existed before that.
By the time anyone thought to ask, all the founding members were dead (presumably not murdered).
Many of those founding members contributed to the stories in this book. I’ll be honest, aside from Sayers and Christie, I don’t recognize any of the other names. However, A.A. Milne was also one of the founding members (he wrote more than Pooh stories!). Early on, the only requirements for membership were that the authors write detective stories, “It being understood that the term ‘detective-novel’ does not include adventure-stories or ‘thrillers’ or stories in which the detection is not a main interest,” and that the members attend regular dinners.
Sorry Americans.
Yes, it was a dining club. I love that. People bond over shared interests and food, so it’s only logical that make meals an unnegotiable part of the charter. The club is (it still exists) invitation only, too. New members go through an initiation ceremony devised by Sayers and G.K. Chesterton, and if that’s not the coolest thing I’ve ever heard of I don’t know what it. After completing the ritual the president pronounces a blessing on the initiate.
Symons was president from 1976-1985.
You are duly elected a member of the Detection Club,
And if you fail to remember your promises and break even
One of our unwritten rules,
May other writers anticipate your plots
May total strangers sue you for libel
May your pages swarm with misprints
And your sales continually diminish.
But should you, as no doubt you will, recall these promises
And observe the rules,
May reviewers rave over you
And literary editors lunch you
May book clubs bargain for you
And women’s magazines carve you up
May films be made for you (and keep your plots)
And American universities embalm you.