The other night I read JD Cowan’s excellent think piece on comfort in entertainment. If you have the time, I encourage you to read it through. He makes some excellent points regarding what made our old entertainment so rich and how it’s been cheapened through cynicism and the desire to be edgy, mature, what have you. Cowan also makes the case for drawing from the past to bring a new level of comfort into today’s entertainment.
Things are going to get better. We’re already seeing the shift.
To say that we’re uncomfortable seems counterintuitive in an era where we never have to leave the house. Want toilet paper, a prepared meal, sex, or movie? Just open an app on your phone. You might have to get off the couch at some point, but not to go any further than the front door. Unfortunately, most of what’s held up as entertainment is extremely distressing. Just think about it. The bulk of Netflix’s new programing is serial killer themed. Game of Thrones is nihilism on a plate. Even network procedurals end on lingering cliffhangers.
And sitcoms reinforce the idea that we’re all pieces of excrement.
I don’t watch any of those things, or if I do I don’t binge them. They’re not satisfying to my soul. I don’t need to fill my head with evil, nor do I take any joy in seeing its execution. I don’t think humanity, for all its faults, is a blight on creation. Whatever dopamine rush other people get from the constant horror show of modern media just doesn’t work on me. So like Cowan, I look to the past for the bulk of my entertainment and search out the new things that work in the old modes.
New things are out there, and we don’t have to go too far into the past.
For the last week my mom has had a bad cold and been going to bed early. I could stay up not very late and watch whatever I want. The other night I found myself endlessly scrolling, trying to will myself to commit to something I’d never seen before. As the minutes ticked by, it got too late for a movie. Soon it would be too late for anything other than a sitcom (and I don’t really like those, even the old ones).
So I decided to watch Burn Notice for the umpteenth time.
What is Burn Notice, you ask? It’s my comfort TV show of choice. I miss these characters if I haven’t seen them in a while, and after all dust settles at the end of every episode the bad guys are punished and our heroes can put the central mystery aside for a few minutes to enjoy having made the world a better place. It’s a show that’s kept me company during lonely times, and a show that I’ve sometimes shared with friends.
And you only have to go back to 2007 for it.
But consider newer fare, like The ARK on sci-fi, which I’m always going on about. Or Hallmark movies. Or even Gutfeld! on Fox News. All programs that are still in production, which take a hard look at life’s difficulties and still leave us smiling. It’s why I hope The ARK finds an audience, and how I can watch a news program before bed and still sleep. The popularity of Hallmark movies, while not my cup of tea, suggests to me that there’s an audience for romance without a side of serial killers.
We can make the world a more comforting place.
There’s no going back in time. There’s no going back to the 50’s, before the internet, Chinese viruses and spy balloons, or the complex moral dilemmas of modern medicine. But if our entertainment would show us traditional things as normal, maybe some of that would spill off the screen and into our day-to-day. I think it would.
Better that than serial killers.