Sam Raimi’s 2002 Spider-Man movie arrived at just the right time in my life. It was a summer with some amazing moments and devastating losses. It was the summer I graduated high school and we had a wonderful open house attended by so many kind people. But it was also the summer we were forced to leave a church community that at times felt more like family than family. It was the last summer I found myself completely comfortable in a group of amazing new friends.
2002 was the summer my uncle, my mom’s only brother, was killed by a drunk driver.
At the time my favorite superhero was Spider-Man, and I watched the trailer over and over again. Sure, Toby Maguire seemed a little too dorky for Peter Parker, even compared to the original comic book character, and let’s not even get started on the organic web-shooters debate. And sure, Willem Dafoe’s Green Goblin costume was best described as that of a rejected Power Ranger villain.
I didn’t care. I was ready for it. I loved it. And I still love it.
So it was unfortunate that I was so disinterested in Spider-Man: No Way Home, given that it features the return of Maguire and Dafoe among others. I’ve followed Spidy through all his movie incarnations and appreciate them for what they are. Tom Holland has a fun take on the character, nothing against him. I’m just weary and wary of the new MCU. Nevertheless, this weekend I finally sat down, with a cup of coffee loaded with nootropics and lapful of cats, and watched the whole extended edition.
And I felt every one of those extra fifteen minutes.
Even if I could, I won’t try to summarize a story that anyone who cares probably already knows. Besides, I spent large portions distracted by my phone, because this is definitely a movie that doesn’t require your full attention. However I still have something to say, and it’s not something I’ve seen anyone else mention yet.
No Way Home reveals the superiority of Raimi’s original above all others.
The whole movie leads up to Maguire’s entrance, saving him to the last for a reason. Not only is he the older mentor that Holland and Garfield’s characters need, he’s also the one who carries the oldest wounds. Maguire plays Parker with a wry melancholy that suits a kind-hearted man who has been treated unkindly by life and just keeps getting back up again.
That’s my Spider-Man.
And let’s not overlook the villains. Alfred Molina’s Doc Ock is arguably the most tragic villain in comic book movie history, so it’s appropriate that he have the most significant moment of redemption. Unless you’re a super-fan, you’d be forgiven for not remembering Electro and Sandman are here too, because it’s Dafoe’s Green Goblin (now with a better costume) that drives the story. It’s the first villain from the first Spider-Man that drives the movie! Not a character developed in recent years.
The OG Peter Parker and GG being so necessary speaks to the strength of Raimi’s work.
Or maybe I’m just showing my age. The story of that first Spider-Man is one of high highs, low lows, and terrible loss. Which is exactly what I was going through at the time. As you may have guessed, I can most relate to Maguire’s Spidy in No Way Home more than the others, too. Does that make him the best? For me, that’s an unequivocal yes. Of all the major comic book characters, Spider-Man has always had the biggest heart and the hardest time.
I feel that.
If you haven’t seen No Way Home yet, don’t bother. I won’t be going back anytime soon, if ever. But what I wouldn’t give to go back to 2002, with all its trials and blessings, knowing what I know now. But thanks to the movie, I can at least remind myself of where I was and how far I’ve come.