I wouldn’t normally do two movie reviews in a row, but I don’t normally stay up late watching movies like I did last night.
While out raking leaves, I listened to a short documentary about Lizzie Borden and her lasting influence. It was actually the audio from a video essay, which I’ve linked to and is probably the best way to experience it. In the piece host Dean Karayanis spends most of it discussing the 1975 made-for-TV movie The Legend of Lizzie Borden starring Elizabeth Montgomery, which one Borden biographer says is the most accurate portrayal of the woman and her trial.
Samantha Stephens, a coldblooded killer? Say it ain’t so!
Suddenly I was in the mood for good, old fashioned, 70’s horror lite, so I was pleased to see that The Legend of Lizzie Borden is included with Amazon Prime (the VHS is $100). It’s only about an hour and half, and Mom went to bed early, so I figured why not? I’m sure I knew this movie existed, and now thanks to the power of streaming, things that were obscure are now readily available.
For better or for worse.
I’ve never been terribly interested in the Borden case, to be honest. Maybe I just prefer my mysteries solved. But this telling of the infamous case is so highly regarded, and it fit my mood at the moment. I put it on, figuring I’d stop about halfway through and go to bed. Instead I stayed up, held in its eerie grip.
Network TV back then was much more frightening than it is now.
The movie opens like any other low-budget period piece, showing happy people milling around outside. One of the sweet, old neighbors knocks at the Bordens’ front door and Lizzie answers, looking a little out of it. She says in a monotone that someone has killed her father. Naturally, the neighbor goes inside and sees the mangled body. There are some jump cuts and scary musical stings, before we suddenly cut to a cheery opening credits sequence that reminded me of Cheers.
The old-timey music stays, as do the thrills.
Montgomery was ten years older than her character, though it was later learned that she and Borden were sixth cousins, once removed. Family history notwithstanding, while she’s a little too old for the part, she’s brilliant. Not every actor can convey so much with a vacant stare, but she could. Just as viewers of the time wouldn’t be quick to accept wholesome Sam Stephens as a murderess, the people of Lizzie's time didn’t want to believe that a woman could hack up her parents with an ax.
But by the end of the movie we do.
Sure there are shades of Hitchcock’s Psycho here (how could there not?), but it’s done much more cleverly than Carrie and other imitators. Lizzie clearly isn’t all there (like Norman), and her relationship with her father is questionable (similar to Norman’s relationship with his mother). Nudity is all but shown, though this time it’s the killer getting naked and not the victim. And the final shot is just a spine-chilling look.
The Legend of Lizzie Borden is its own movie, as attested to by all the awards and nominations it received. Amazon’s transfer isn’t great, and the story won’t be to everyone’s taste, but like the movie I discussed yesterday, it’s an effective story that relies on plot and characters more than shock and special effects.
Lesson in that.