Yesterday I finally took the time to sit down and watch The Northman, or as I called it, the live action Lion King remake with vikings.
If you don’t get the joke, both The Northman and The Lion King are loosely connected to Hamlet. In The Northman, young Amleth witnesses his father’s murder at the hand of his uncle and escapes until he is old and strong enough to get his revenge. In the meantime, Amleth’s mother marries her husband’s killer, which complicates things when Amleth inevitably returns to sate his bloodlust.
So yeah, just like Simba.
This time the familiar story is told amidst the backdrop of ancient viking society, with all its paganism and savage violence. One thing that really impressed me is the cinematography. Iceland has arguably never looked more beautiful on film. Director Robert Eggers uses very long takes, so the fight scenes aren’t the rapid cut jarring shaky cam shots we know from The Lord of the Rings. The final battle is mostly in silhouette by the light of a volcano, which almost always makes for a stunning tableau.
Alexander Skarsgård as Amleth is huge, even more enormous than he was as Tarzan.
On his journey he meets and falls in love with the witch Olga, who knows how to “break men’s minds.” I guess she’s the anti-Ophelia, since she doesn’t go insane and clarifies Amleth’s purpose. He’s also guided by various mystics and the gods themselves, though this is hardly a fantasy story.
It’s just fantastic.
As with Braveheart, much has been made of the violence in The Northman, which I think is overstated. Yes, it’s brutal. But I’ve seen far worse in movies. Unlike Braveheart, I didn’t find The Northman to be as inspiring or entertaining. Eggers’ objective doesn’t seem to entertain as much as to give the audience a mystical experience. That’s fine. I think he delivers on his intention. I’m just starting to miss the days when Story wasn’t sacrificed in the name of Experience.
But that’s what Hollywood uses to keep us coming back.
Neither Amleth nor Olga is as defined as William Wallace, more archetypes than characters, as is befitting a myth. I suppose. The consequence is that the shelf life of The Northman won’t be as long as Mel Gibson’s masterpiece. Another reason I think it lacks resonance is because fighting for revenge isn’t as meaningful as fighting for freedom.
FREEDOM!
Another lesson for storytellers is that it’s useful to incorporate mythic elements and symbols into our work. This is something Eggers does very well. We may not understand their meaning or significance, but on a very deep level we know they are there. When something flows with electric current of truth, we feel it. This is the rare movie that allows men to be men, never denying their brute strength, and women to be women, who rely on cunning and subterfuge. If that’s toxic, I want more of that. The spirituality may be muddled here, but a certain degree of truth is there for the taking.