This article will contain spoilers for Battle Ground, so don’t say I didn’t warn you.
After a lengthy hiatus, Jim Butcher gave us Dresden Files fans two novels published just a few months apart. That may have sounded like a reward for our patience, but in this reader’s humble opinion it was not. Butcher’s editor should have sat him down and made him trim those tomes down. There’s just too much fat to really enjoy the meat of the story.
I digress.
That said, I sometimes miss the characters Butcher created and often want to revisit their world. Despite the misses among the hits, unless he suddenly goes woke I’ll see the series through. It’s been my companion through many major chapters of my life, and at the end of the day it’s just entertaining.
There are songs I don’t want to hear again because they remind me of bad times. But no matter how sad or depressed or heartbroken I was when reading a Harry Dresden story, I can always go back.
The most recent novel, Battle Ground, is full of fan service and Avengers: Endgame bloat. It moves the series away from the hardboiled detective novels that defined the early stories and becomes a comic book movie on page. It didn’t sit right with me. It still doesn’t. Fortunately, I think Butcher is skilled enough to course correct.
His new novella, The Law, proves it.
I listened to The Law on my way to and from BasedCon, and it was just the right length for the drive. It opens with Harry grieving his losses. At the end of Battle Ground he’s lost Murphy, and Susan will always have a special place in his heart. Winning the battle came at a great cost, and it’s not just what was taken away from him. Harry carries a burden for the things he had to do.
Harry is dangerous, but he’s not a psychopath.
And then he gets a case. Like the old days. A former sex worker who turned her life around by starting a small business is getting sued by her old pimp. Of course, things aren’t as simple as that and it doesn’t take long for Harry to bump into some things that bump back in the night. What gives me hope for the series is that Harry (meaning, the author) has self-imposed restrictions on how he can handle the situation. It’s in character, increases the drama, and improves the story.
The shorter form also means Butcher has to prove he can still tell a lean story.
Murphy’s death upset a lot fans. While Harry’s cat has to be pushing 30 by now, and I appreciate Butcher’s kindness to animals, it does seem a little unfair. Whether or not killing off Murphy will be justified depends on how Butcher uses it to develop the characters and overarching story. I think the opening pages of The Law shows he’s off to a good start.
Butcher has kept his politics to himself, as far as I know. This novel, arriving in this time, does offer some intriguing hints. It’s very much a power to the people tale. Harry could let the Faerie Courts sort out the mortals’ problems, but he thinks that normal people should make the decisions. Not the queens and lords. Interesting.
All that said, The Law is just a good story and more in line with what I want from Harry and company. So if you haven’t given up Butcher yet, I’d say give it a chance.
Here's a link to the Kindle version. If you're more audiobook inclinded, Butcher reads it himself and does a very good job, even if he makes Harry sound like John Wayne.