I’m so thankful I’m not a film critic.
There are many in my online social circle who feel compelled to see every new release so that they can be critics. Today they might go see the latest superhero movie, tomorrow a self-indulgent character study that takes three and a half hours to say people are horrible, and then a musical over the weekend. Sometimes they might go in expecting to hate something and come out respecting it. More often than not, I imagine, they’re proven right.
Or, more likely, they have no strong feelings about the film.
It’s just meh.
Maybe the critics are the heroes we need. I certainly respect their work and dedication, while also being thankful that theirs is not my calling. For a few years I thought it might be, and I saw so many movies that I immediately forgot at best, and made me miserable for days at worst. Of course, I saw a few movies I loved. But those were movies I would’ve chosen to watch without any sort of obligation.
Clint Eastwood’s masterful Richard Jewell comes to mind.
In a world overwhelmed by content, I’d rather watch movies that have stood the test of time. I know it’s cool to say that Casablanca isn’t that great. The fact that it’s been studied, praised, and screened countless times over the decades says otherwise. It may not be to your taste, but there’s no denying that it’s a great film and well worth your 102 minutes. I don’t like High Noon, at all, yet its significance is undeniable and I’m sure I’ll watch it again someday.
We have to know the past to talk about the present.
Too many online critics aren’t well-versed in the classics, and thus lack the knowledge and vocabulary to talk about the new stuff. There’s a popular YouTube channel with two engaging hosts that I want to love. I won’t name them, because I’m about to put them on blast. Their channel is split between reactions to older movies and talking about current movies and pop culture. Unfortunately, they know so little film history that their takes aren’t terribly helpful.
Hopefully, as they continue going back and increasing their knowledge base, things will improve.
You’ll never be a better person for having seen “all the movies.” But if you can let me know that you understand the language and history of film, your commentary will be better and I’ll take your opinions more seriously.
And if you want to tell good stories…
You can’t go wrong by studying the masters. Reviewing books and movies is fun but, again, it’s not my calling. I think I’m called to create. So I don’t need to see all of the uninspired, derivative content that’s filling the production pipeline. It’s more to my advantage to know what’s great and try to figure out why. Ideas can come from anywhere, anything. But great inspiration comes from great things.
So I want to focus on things that are great.